Monday, November 3, 2014

Radiation Therapy after Prostate Surgery: The Guidelines Say Yes, My Doctor Says No

Some men prostate cancer are faced with the realization that treatment of their prostate cancer may require multimodal treatment including some combination of surgery, radiation therapy and/or hormone therapy. The combined ASTRO/AUA (American Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology/American Urological Association) Guideline for "Adjuvant and Salvage Radiotherapy after Radical Prostatectomy" makes a number of statements regarding the use of radiation therapy after surgery that can be confusing to patients and practitioners.

In this blog we review the statements from the ASTRO/AUA Guideline regarding adjuvant radiation therapy and the data supporting them.



The Guidelines are supported, mostly, by the data from three randomized trials of adjuvant radiation therapy (ART) versus observation for patients after radical prostatectomy (RP). The SWOG trial began first in 1988 followed by the EORTC and most recently the ARO trial. However, the EORTC trial had more than double the sample size compared to the other two trials. All three trials enrolled patients with pathologic stage, pT3, disease and/or positive surgical margins. However, they differed in that the ARO trial excluded men with a persistently elevated PSA after RP, whereas these patients were included in the other two trials.
All three trials used a relatively low radiation dose of 60 Gray (most radiation oncologist argue that adequate, contemporary treatment of prostate cancer requires 80 Gray), and only the more recent ARO trial used modern 3-dimensional treatment planning. Central pathology review was available for the majority, but not all, patients in the 3 trials. The primary endpoint was metastasis-free survival in the SWOG study, versus progression-free survival in the other 2 trials. Finally, because it began earlier, the initial SWOG publication and a more recent update had longer follow-up than in the other trials.


Vital Statistics:

SWOG 8794

Thompson et al. JAMA 2006; 296: 2329.
Thompson et al. JUrol 2009; 181: 956.
Initiated: 1988
Sample Size: 425
Inclusion Criteria: pT3* and/or SM+ (Positive Surgical Margin); 15.7% pT2*
Patients with Persistent PSA Elevation following Surgery: Approximately 1/3rd
Radiation Therapy Dose: 60-64 Gray
Primary Endpoint: Metastases-Free Survival
Median Follow-up: 12.6 years

EORTC 22911

Bolla et al. Lancet 2005; 366: 572.
Van der Kwast et al. JCO 2006; 26: 4178.
Bolla et al. Lancet. 2012 Dec 8;380(9858):2018-27
Initiated: 1992
Sample Size: 1,005
Inclusion Criteria: pT3* and/or SM+ (>1/3rd pT2*)
Patients with Persistent PSA Elevation following Surgery: 11%
Radiation Therapy Dose: 60 Gray
Primary Endpoint: clinical or biochemical Progression-Free Survival (PFS)
Median Follow-up: 10.6 years

ARO 96-02/ AUO 09/95
Wiegel et al. JCO 2009; 27: 2898.
Initiated: 1997
Sample Size: 388
Inclusion Criteria: pT3* with or without SM+ (No Lymph Node Metastases)
Patients with Persistent PSA Elevation following Surgery: 20%, were excluded
Radiation Therapy Dose: 60 Gray (using modern 3-D conformal techniques)
Primary Endpoint: biochemical Progression-Free Survival (PFS)
Median Follow-up: 4.5 years

pT2: organ-confined prostate cancer at RP
pT3: non-organ confined disease at RP (includes pT3a: extraprostatic extension and pT3b: seminal vesicle invasion)
SM+: positive surgical margins



Guideline Statement 1.

  • Patients who are being considered for management of localized prostate cancer with radical prostatectomy should be informed of the potential for adverse pathologic findings that portend a higher risk of cancer recurrence and that these findings may suggest a potential benefit of additional therapy after surgery. (Clinical Principle)

Guideline Statement 2.

  • Patients with adverse pathologic findings including seminal vesicle invasion, positive surgical margins, and extraprostatic extension should be informed that adjuvant radiotherapy, compared to radical prostatectomy only, reduces the risk of biochemical (PSA) recurrence, local recurrence, and clinical progression of cancer.
  • They should also be informed that the impact of adjuvant radiotherapy on subsequent metastases and overall survival is less clear; one of two randomized controlled trials that addressed these outcomes indicated a benefit but the other trial did not demonstrate a benefit. However, the other trial was not powered to test the benefit regarding metastases and overall survival. (Clinical Principle)

Guideline Statement 3.

  • Physicians should offer adjuvant radiotherapy to patients with adverse pathologic findings at prostatectomy including seminal vesicle invasion, positive surgical margins, or extraprostatic extension because of demonstrated reductions in biochemical recurrence, local recurrence, and clinical progression. (Standard; Evidence Strength: Grade A)



Biochemical Recurrence or Progression Free Survival

All three studies demonstrate a higher proportion of men experiencing a biochemical (PSA) recurrence after RP and ART. The risk of recurrence was decreased approximately 50% in meta-analysis data from all three trials including in the guideline indicating that ART reduces the risk of biochemical (PSA) recurrence in men with high-risk of recurrence after radical prostatectomy.

Biochemical Progression-Free Survival
RP alone
Hazard Ratio
10 years
0.43, P<0.01
10 years
0.49, P<0.01
5 years
0.53, P=0.002

Locoregional and Metastatic Recurrence or Recurrence-Free Survival

This statistic refers to the proportion of patients who develop nodal metastasis or evidence of prostate cancer in the pelvis that can be treated with curative radiation. These numbers are expectedly low, even for patients with advanced disease. The ARO96-02 trial did not report locoregional recurrence, but both the SWOG and EORTC studies demonstrated a benefit for ART with regard to locoregional relapse.

Local Relapse-Free Survival
RP alone
Hazard Ratio
10 years
NR, P<0.01
10 years
0.45, p<0.01
5 years
Not Reported


Metastatic recurrence refers to the proportion of patients who develop recurrent prostate cancer outside of the pelvis, are therefore not curable by local treatments like radiation and require systemic treatment like androgen deprivation and/or chemotherapy. The results for metastatic recurrence (and metastasis-free survival, MFS) are less clear with conflicting results among the studies. The SWOG study demonstrated a benefit to ART, while the EORTC did not and ARO96-02 has too few events at current follow-up. In the SWOG study, MFS was defined as the presence of metastases or death from any cause. In the SWOG study, 72% of the deaths occurred in men without metastases and there were only 5 more cancer deaths in the observation group – perhaps leading to the significant finding in this study.[1]

Metastases and Metastases-Free Survival (MFS)
RP alone
Hazard Ratio
10 years
MFS:0.71, P=0.016
10 years
MFS: 0.99, P=0.94
4.5 years


Overall Survival

Overall Survival (OS) was improved for patients receiving ART in the SWOG study, but not the EORTC or ARO96-02 studies. Mirroring the MFS data, there are conflicting results for OS among the studies.

Deaths and Overall Survival (OS)
RP alone
Hazard Ratio
10 years
OS: 74%
0.72, P=0.023
10 years
OS: 76.9%
1.18, P=0.2
4.5 years
Deaths: 3.4%


All three studies consisted of a heterogeneous group of patients including patients with low-, intermediate- and high-risk features and variation in Gleason score, SM+ and pathological stage. When looking at these subgroups, ART appears to have the most benefit for patients with:
  • Positive Surgical Margins (SM+)
  • Gleason Sum ≥ 7

Other than biochemical (PSA) recurrence-free survival, the benefit to ART is unclear in patients with:
  • Gleason 6
  • Extraprostatic extension in the absence of SM+
  • Seminal vesicle invasion (pT3)

A future blog will discuss the subgroup analyses in greater detail.


  • Adjuvant radiation therapy (ART) is an option for men with advanced prostate cancer and adverse features after radical prostatectomy.
  • The ASTRO/AUA Guidelines are based on the data from three large, randomized clinical trials:
    • SWOG 8794
    • EORTC 22911
    • ARO 96-02/ AUO 09/95
  • Patients who undergo ART will have an improvement in biochemical (PSA) and locoregional recurrence.
    • The impact of ART on distant metastases and overall survival is less clear.
  • Subgroup analyses indicate that patients with positive surgical margins and Gleason Score ≥ 7 are most likely to benefit from ART.
    • The benefit of ART is unclear in patients with Gleason 6, extraprostatic extension or seminal vesicle invasion.


This blog was written by Mark W. Ball, MD. This blog is the first of a series on "Radiation Therapy after Prostate Surgery."  Dr. Ball is a 5th year urology resident at the Brady Urological Institute at Johns Hopkins and looking forward to a career in urologic oncology.




[1] Cheng et al J Urol 182: 2531, 2009


  1. hello everyone in this forum i am little bit ashamed to share this marvelous story about a great spell caster who helped me enlarge my small penis size through his herbal mixture cream,i was heartbroken before because i have a very small penis about 3 inches which was so annoying and shameful i could not satisfy my wife in bed ,,my marriage was really breaking and i needed help urgently,i have used pills,vaccines,drugs,surgery but none one faithful day as i was browsing through the internet i saw few comments on a forum about how Mr MARK HENRY from UK testified of how he helped him enlarge his penis and also cured his MOM diabetes type 2 disease,,i contacted him through his email he replied and gave me steps to follow and i did just as he said ,and he sent me the herbal cream to me through UPS and i received it within 4 days and used the herbal cream for just 14 days to my greatest surprise my penis that was 3 inches before enlarge to 10.5 inches long when fully erected ,for just two weeks of using his herbal mixture cream ,,wow my wife loved me more and was so happy that i can satisfy her very well now in bed ,,i even last longer than before thank you so much DR James for making life a better one to live in if you are out there having similar problems please contact him now on his email or whatsapp and call him on +2349055637784 thanks

  2. Hello everyone i am very happy to meet the Dr John , I have been humiliated many times in relationships due to the fact of not being able to satisfy my girlfriend because I had a very small penis. i had so many relationship called off because of my situation, i have used so many product which i found on line but none could offer me the kind of help i searched for. I was going through some comments on Facebook when I saw a testimony about this specialist called Dr John, and how he helped solve the testifier relationship issues regarding to their sex life, so i decided to seek his help too following the email I saw ( so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, and I told him my story, Dr John sent me some herbal pills for Penis Enlargement, Within 2 week of usage, i began to feel the enlargement of my penis, ” and now it just 5 weeks of using his products my penis is about 9 inches longer, all thanks to the great Dr John, I believe their are so many people going through the same thing which I went through that why I decided to tell the world how I got help from this man ( call him or what-apps him through +2348060259313

  3. Hello everyone. I was heartbroken because i had very small penis, not nice to satisfy a woman, i had so many relationship called off because of my situation, i have used so many product which i found online but none could offer me the help i searched for. i saw some few comments about this doctor called Dr. OMOHAN and I decided to email him on: so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words with his herbal cream for Penis Enlargement, Within 1 week of it, i began to feel the enlargement of my penis, " and now it just 2 weeks of using his products my penis is about 9 inches longer and strong. I'm so happy..feel free to contact DR OMOHAN on his Email: or you can also call him on the whatsapp contact +2348164816038

  4. The doctors said Herpes virus do not have medical cure because the virus is capable of hiding within the human cells, it remains protected from your immune system. Herpes isn’t a special virus – your immune system has the tools to fight it back. But because it is able to lay dormant in protected cells, your immune system is unable to remove it from your body,But with strong reactive herbal medication is capable of getting rid of the virus gradually and totally from your body without damaging any of your cells,natural herbs kills the virus totally not just reducing the out break. Get natural herbs cure from Dr. Oshuku ( or WhatsApp number +2348130419838

  5. hello everyone here i want to tell the whole world about DR AKIOYA herbal mixture product ...Dr AKIOYA penis enlargement herbal product in Africa.This is the only Male Penis Enlargement product has been used by men around the world like USA,CANADA,AUSTRALIA,BELGIUM,SWEDEN,GERMANY,UK,SINGAPORE,MALAYSIA AND SO MANY MORE supplement that has been PROVEN to-enlarge your penis – safely, quickly, and importantly – PERMANENTLY.Full DR AKIOYA Penis Enlargement product when used will Increase in penis length by 1-5 inches Increase in penis width by 20%helps in preventing Premature Ejaculation.Achieved longer, rock hard erections All gains in penis length and width are 100% permanent Full AKIOYA Penis Enlargement product is also:100% Herbal, 100% Safest with no side effect and its of two types I have the one for enlargement and for reduction and your advised to use it by message 100% Satisfaction and Money Back Guarantee. DR.AKIOYA, About my products i have herbal product and oil 100% Permanent Guaranteed resulting it on your body where you feel you want to reduce or enlarge which will help you to be strong and you get the desirable size you want-within 3-5 days and when you get your desirable size you are advised to stop using it and the results you gain will remain permanent We also do deliveries all over AFRICA, and worldwide so i would like to know first when do you need the product.for more information call or whatsapp Dr.AKIOYA +2348105257464 or call +2348105257464 email
    note DR AKIOYA also have herbal medicines to problems like
    DIABETES type 1 and type 2
    HPV 123

  6. I want to share this wonderful testimony to the Good people all over the world on how I was able to Enlarge my Penis by Dr. zubby. I was living a shameful life from my young age, just last month as I was browsing on the internet about Penis size and Enlargement Products, I saw a testimony of a Man called George , testifying of how he was able to get his penis Enlarged by Dr. zubby and I decided to also Email Dr.zubby for my small penis size and he quickly respond to me and gave me the normal instructions which i did and then he shipped the product to me here in the united state which i received in just 3 working days and today i am very happy because i started seeing positive changes in my penis size in just 7 days of use. Dr zubby herbal product is the best recommended for you and to whom ever suffering from this shame or having any other diseases as well should Contact this great herbal doctor via his Email : and WhatsApp Him on   +2348070673249

  7. Greetings everyone.

    i am very happy to share this little awesome testimony about Dr OKISIN a great herbal doctor who help me enlarge my penis size.3.2 cm to 8.3 cm longer with his herbal cream mixture, my girlfriend is now so amazed with the autonomous size of my penis , if you you are also in need of help on how to enlarge your penis to become bigger and stronger I advIce you to contact Dr OKISIN on his email ( ) you or contact on whatsapp number +2348149508633 because he is one of the best herbal doctor that i can only show you up to, if your penis is 4.2 cm and want to get it reach 9.2 cm within three weeks i Dr OKISIN is also specialized on  breast and boobs enlargement i advise you to contact him for help   DR OKISIN whatsapp number +2348149508633...........

  8. I was diagnosed as HEPATITIS B carrier in 2013 with fibrosis of the
    liver already present. I started on antiviral medications which
    reduced the viral load initially. After a couple of years the virus
    became resistant. I started on HEPATITIS B Herbal treatment from
    ULTIMATE LIFE CLINIC ( in March, 2020. Their
    treatment totally reversed the virus. I did another blood test after
    the 6 months long treatment and tested negative to the virus. Amazing
    treatment! This treatment is a breakthrough for all HBV carriers.