Thursday, June 26, 2014

Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy for Bladder Cancer: What Does It All Mean?

Patients diagnosed with muscle-invasive bladder cancer can and should look to their physicians for guidance in selecting the best treatment plan for them.  In the ideal setting, a strong patient-physician relationship will facilitate the asking and answering of the many questions that come along with a new diagnosis of bladder cancer.  The majority of these questions, however, will inevitably center around the most crucial of all:

What do we do next?

In today’s world there exist many reasonable options for cancer therapy, ranging from surgery to chemotherapy to radiation.  While it may sometimes hold true that variety is the spice of life, for a patient encountering bladder cancer for the first time – forced to investigate a world which had never even previously existed to them – these options can quickly become more overwhelming than reassuring.  Therefore, today’s blog entry aims to address one of the most prevalent questions facing patients considering surgery: the role of neoadjuvant chemotherapy (or chemotherapy prior to surgery).


Historically, in patients eligible for surgery, the use of chemotherapy was considered only after surgery had been performed.  The rationale for this is no less intuitive than it seems – if you can remove a cancer, you remove it…now!  And while this dogma still frequently holds true, surgical and medical oncologists have learned over the past several years that sometimes it is best to delay surgery for a short period to allow for treatment with chemotherapy first.  Such treatment occurring prior to surgery is called “neo-adjuvant” therapy, while the more traditional “adjuvant” therapy refers to additional treatment after surgery.

In recent years, large collaborative associations both in the United States and abroad have recommended the use of neo-adjuvant chemotherapy (NAC) in treatment of muscle-invasive bladder cancer.  You may find yourself asking, though, why would a patient need chemotherapy before surgery if the cancer can be removed with surgery anyway?  On what grounds were these recommendations based?  What are the pros and cons of using neoadjuvant chemotherapy?  Finally, and perhaps most importantly, are these recommendations right for me?  In this month’s Journal of Urology, Dr. Hugh Lavery and colleagues closely examined the best-available data on the topic and set out to answer these and other questions surrounding the use of NAC in the setting of muscle-invasive bladder cancer.[1]

Why would a patient need chemotherapy before surgery if the cancer can be removed with surgery alone?

As Dr. Lavery and colleagues describe, the overall cure rate for bladder cancer after radical surgery (i.e. surgery to remove a cancerous organ along with its blood supply and adjacent tissues, such as lymph nodes) is substantially lower than that of other cancers we treat.  The reasons for this are not entirely clear, and it has led urologists to investigate what else can be done to increase the number of patients who are cured of bladder cancer with treatment.  One patient group that helps to understand the need for multiple treatment approaches, or “multimodal therapy,” is that which underwent radical cystectomy (i.e. removal of the bladder) but were then found to have no evidence of cancer remaining in the bladder at all (i.e. pathological T-stage zero, or pT0 for short).  This can be achieved if either 1) the entire tumor was removed during local excision of the mass, or 2) the cancer in the bladder was treated completely using NAC.

From following patients with pT0 disease, we have learned that even when there is no cancer left in a bladder that was removed, not all of these patients are cured in the long term.  This tells us that in some cases, a number of cancer cells too few to be seen on imaging had left the bladder and traveled elsewhere in the body.  While we believe surgery provides the best chance of curing any cancer in and around the bladder, it is no match for cells that have traveled elsewhere.  Thus, we look to systemic (i.e. entire body) treatments such as chemotherapy to assist in eradicating cancer from the body completely.

On what grounds are recommendations supporting NAC based?

Just like a contested case in court, the jury must ultimately look back to the evidence for guidance.  In the case of NAC, the evidence stems from four large randomized-controlled trials (RCTs) which compare patients who received NAC to those who did not.[2-6]  Although understanding the attributes of different studies could make up its own blog entry, graduate-level course, or even research career, we will just say here that a randomized-controlled trial is widely considered the best possible design for clinical trials.  So what did these trials reveal?  A small (5-10% absolute and 16-33% relative improvement in survival) – but significant – overall survival benefit in patients who received NAC prior to surgery.

As could be expected, there was significantly better survival among patients who achieved pT0 status, whether they underwent NAC or not.  The main advantage was that more patients who received NAC were found to be pT0 than those who went straight to surgery (and it is hypothesized that the increased number of pT0 patients accounts for the survival benefits observed).  Of course, even well-performed trials are not perfect, and Dr. Lavery and colleagues describe the limitations of the studies in detail.  Acknowledging this, the trials seem to confirm two critical pieces of information: 1) patients with no visible tumor in the bladder at the time of surgery have better survival, and 2) use of NAC gives patients a better chance of being tumor-free at surgery.  While these trials are not perfect, they provide the best available insight as to the effects of NAC in the setting of surgery.

What are the pros and cons of NAC?

Like most treatments, chemotherapy offers potential benefit at the risk of unwanted side effects.  The hope is of course that NAC, in combination with surgery, will cure the body of cancer completely.  As described above, we have fairly strong evidence that these treatments can achieve that in some patients.  Unfortunately, many cancers treated with chemotherapy will not respond, and in these cases, patients are subjected to the side effects of treatment without gaining significant benefit.  Identifying which tumors will and will not respond to chemotherapy is an area of active research, but as of yet we cannot predict this, and therefore we cannot restrict NAC to only those patients who will benefit from it.  In addition to the toxic side effects of chemotherapy, another drawback of NAC is that it inevitably delays surgery, usually for between 3 and 6 months.  While it is generally presumed that chemotherapy protects against the spread of cancer during this time, there are no studies which have looked specifically at this question.  It is therefore impossible to rule out the potential for cancer to spread outside the bladder during the delay prior to surgery.

Are these recommendations right for me?

As described above, the potential benefit of chemotherapy will have to be weighed against its side effects, which can range from life-threatening (e.g. blood disorders) to unpleasant (e.g. nausea).  A discussion with your physician should consider both your body’s ability to tolerate such side effects and your desire to do so in exchange for an uncertain benefit.  In the future, we hope that additional research can allow us to identify which patients will benefit from chemotherapy – and, better yet, lead to the development of more effective, less toxic therapies.  Until that time, deciding whether NAC is the right choice for each individual remains a difficult decision, but one that patients can aim to answer with the support of their friends, family, and healthcare team.



Jeffrey Tosoian, MD
Nilay Gandhi, MD
 This blog entry was written by Brady Urology Residents Jeffrey Tosoian, MD and Nilay Gandhi, MD.  












[1] Hugh J. Lavery, Kristian D. Stensland, Guenter Niegisch, Peter Albers, Michael J. Droller, Pathological T0 Following Radical Cystectomy with or without Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy: A Useful Surrogate, The Journal of Urology, Volume 191, Issue 4, April 2014, Pages 898-906, ISSN 0022-5347, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.juro.2013.10.142.
[2] Advanced Bladder Cancer (ABC) Meta-analysis Collaboration: Neoadjuvant chemotherapy in invasive bladder cancer: update of a systematic review and meta-analysis of individual patient data advanced bladder cancer (ABC) meta-analysis collaboration.  Eur Urol, 48 (2005), p. 202
[3] H.B. Grossman, R.B. Natale, C.M. Tangen et al.  Neoadjuvant chemotherapy plus cystectomy compared with cystectomy alone for locally advanced bladder cancer.  N Engl J Med, 349 (2003), p. 859
[4] A. Sherif, E. Rintala, O. Mestad et al.  Neoadjuvant cisplatin-methotrexate chemotherapy for invasive bladder cancer—Nordic Cystectomy Trial 2 Scand J Urol Nephrol, 36 (2002), p. 419
[5] E. Rintala, E. Hannisdahl, S.D. Fosså et al.  Neoadjuvant chemotherapy in bladder cancer: a randomized study. Nordic Cystectomy Trial I.  Scand J Urol Nephrol, 27 (1993), p. 355
[6] International Collaboration of Trialists, Medical Research Council Advanced Bladder Cancer Working Party (now the National Cancer Research Institute Bladder Cancer Clinical Studies Group), European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Genito-Urinary Tract Cancer Group et al.  International phase III trial assessing neoadjuvant cisplatin, methotrexate, and vinblastine chemotherapy for muscle-invasive bladder cancer: long-term results of the BA06 30894 trial. J Clin Oncol, 29 (2011), p. 2171



10 comments:

  1. Top Private Hospitals in Kolkata can likewise present you the eminence examine you have in order to help you in loads of ways. These hospitals are the greatest way for you to feel contented and it can really help you to pace up your recovery.

    ReplyDelete
  2. - Chứng bệnh tăng huyết áp hiện nay rất phổ biến tại Việt Nam, bệnh huyết áp chủ yếu xảy ra ở người lớn tuôi.
    - Hiện giờ số lượng người mắc bệnh tim tương đối lớn, con số đáng báo động kịp thời.
    - Điều trị bệnh máu nhiễm mỡ tại bệnh viện Thu Cúc uy tín và chất lượng tốt nhất.
    - cách chăm sóc người bị huyết áp thấp cũng đóng vai trò quan trọng giúp cải thiện nhanh chóng tình trạng sức khỏe.
    - Chứng bệnh rối loạn thần kinh thực vật có ảnh hưởng đến chức năng tự động cơ thể bao gồm nhịp tim, huyết áp, mồ hôi và tiêu hóa…
    - Bệnh lý huyết áp thường không bỏ qua ai, vì vậy việc theo dõi huyết áp bình thường là cần thiết để bảo vệ sức khỏe.
    - Chỉ số nhịp tim bình thường là bao nhiêu, các bạn nên tham khảo kỹ để biết cách chăm lo sức khỏe.
    - Tìm hiểu thông tin kiến thức về bệnh viện tim hà nội
    - Triệu chứng thiếu máu não là những căn bệnh rất nguy hiểm hiện nay.

    - Tìm hiểu cao huyết áp nên ăn gì để có những kiến thức cần thiaats cho các bạn.
    - Chỉ số huyết áp bình thường là bao nhiêu rất quan trọng cho mỗi chúng ta để biết tình hình sức khỏe của mình.
    - Tìm hiểu triệu chứng cao huyết áp để có biện pháp chữa trị hiệu quả nhất.
    - Cách giảm mỡ máu hiệu quả tốt nhất hiện nay là gì, mời các bạn tham khảo.
    - Căn bệnh mỡ máu cao ăn gì là tốt nhất và đảm bảo cho sức khỏe nhất hiện nay.
    - Cùng tìm hiểu nguyên nhân tăng huyết áp là gì và cách điều trị thế nào tốt.
    - biến chứng tăng huyết áp rất nguy hiểm cho người bệnh, các bạn không nên coi thường.

    ReplyDelete
  3. My name is Gary David,i just want to share my testimony with the world on how Doctor Trust Help me to enlarge my pines. Please read my good news carefully and i am sure it will affect your life positively on how you will also enlarge your pines,because i know some many people out there also need his help!

    I came across so many comments about Dr Trust Penis Enlargement Medicine some weeks ago, though I had really wanted my penis to be large, long and thick,because i was not able to have sex with my wife..It was really affecting our marriage and my wife was about to divorce me. I had about 8.128cm – 3.2 inches before. Am really amazed on the fast results archived within 3 days of using Dr. Trust Penis Enlargement Medicine. It work and now I have got 22.87cm – 10.5 inches now. And my wife love it more now, i began to feel the enlargement of my penis, This went on for a little period of about 5 days and to my surprise my wife keeps screaming that she love my big dick now. And my penis is now 10.5 inches long on erection and off course very large round. I am very happy for this Penis Enlargement experience. He can help with all kinds of cure you may need as flows:

    Pines Enlargement
    Low sperm count
    Weak Erection
    Love spell
    Herpes spell
    HIV spell
    Pregnancy spell
    Marriage for spell
    cancer
    watering sperm
    womb fertilization
    penis erection
    witch craft attack
    s t d diseases
    internal heat
    rashes
    low sperm count
    dairy
    long time sickness
    kidney,heart,lungs,problem
    with doctor,Dr. Trust you are in safe hands your healing is assured
    Email:Ultimatespellcast@gmail.com or Ultimatespellcast@yahoo.com
    Web site http://ultimatespellcast8.wix.com/ultimatespellcas
    Call +2348156885231

    ReplyDelete
  4. I never thought that this my problem of weak erection which was caused by prostate surgery will one day ever come to an end because i was told by several urologist which i contacted both locally and abroad that i can't be cured. I was shamed by the different partners i met and dumped, i lost my power as a man because i could not perform in bed to satisfy them because my erection was so weak and i ejaculate upon entering. A colleague introduced me to www.edlifepanacea.com and i contacted them on info@edlifepanacea.com they assured me that i will be okay if i use their medicine, i got the medicine and used it as recommended and its been over 8 months now and i am still very much okay. I perform awesomely and i last extra long. You too can contact them and get a cure. Thanks admin.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I just want to share this personal story about how my husband survived the problem of NO ERECTIONS after prostate surgery.
    My husband undertook prostate surgery 3 years ago and before then i always looked forward to great sex with him and after the surgery he was unable to achieve any erections, we were bothered and we tried so many drugs, injections and pumps and rings but none could give him an erection to even penetrate. I searched for a cure and got to know about Dr. Hillary who is renowned for curing problems of this nature and he did encouraged me not to give up and he recommended his herbal medication which my hubby took for 3 weeks and today his sexual performance is optimum. You too can contact him for similar problems on hillaconn@gmail.com. A man who cannot satisfy his wife's sexual need is not a real man!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Dr Henry Bude penis ENLARGEMENT is specially designed to increase penis size, stop premature ejaculation and help get a stronger erection. It is a powerful blend of high quality handpicked herbal ingredients that are efficient in increasing the size (length and width) of penis and lovemaking performance in men. It is the product of choice for men who want to restore vigour and achieve bigger and rock-hard erection. This herbal cream, pills and liquid medicine works on all types of erectile dysfunctions and other related male problems,
    Increase libido and stamina, Bigger,
    Fuller and firmer erections,
    Gain up to 3-13 full inches in length,
    Enhance lovemaking pleasure and enjoyment,
    More forceful orgasms and improve erectile quality,
    Cure weak erection and delay foreplay by retaining orgasm,
    Accelerate frequency of Nourish and stimulate the male glands,
    Promote growth of nerve tissue,
    Increase blood flow to the erectile tissue,
    Stops early ejaculation and make more rounds,
    Ingredients, tropical herb extracts.
    The main ingredient of this male enhancement creams, pills and liquid medicines are native African herbs with mixtures, and these herbs have been used since centuries for male enhancement. It carries natural aphrodisiac properties that is said to restore the vitality of manhood by offering enhanced self-confidence and lovemaking ability, contact Dr Henry Bude Now for your Order on. Email : Dr.henrybude@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. CURE YOUR SICKNESS AND DISEASE WITH HERBAL CURE FROM AFRICA.

    Are you in pains or can not find cure for your sickness or disease? Wipe your tears, we are here to cure you of whatever disease or sickness you are battling right now.

    We specialize in all kind of treatment and with the help of Almighty God you will be well again, hurry now and contact us via email: africanherbalcure@gmail.com

    HEALTH IS WEALTH.

    Dr Disu.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My husband left me and our 6 month old daughter at the end of last month. I was and still am devesated. He said he fell out of love with me and that we were no good for each other since all we did was argue and fight. He then changed his story before he left saying he would come back for us after 2 weeks of working and saving up and move us all down to flordia to live so we could raise our daughter without my family’s meddling in our business. Well once he was down there I found this wasn’t true. He told me it was over and that he wanted to sign his rights away to our daughter and he wants to divorce. He claims he is very happy down there and I am happy for him. Turns out I found from one of his friends that he had no intention of coming back and he said that stuff so I wouldn’t over react and cause a scene. I miss him so terribly much..we’ve only been married since Septmeber 2014 and he’s about to turn 21 next month and I am 22. My family says it’s his age that caused this and that he’s scared. I’ve prayed to god every single night to be there for him and to help him grow up and understand what it is he’s doing. Meanwhile my heart..it’s not feeling broken like it first was..yes I’m sad and miss my husband terribly but it’s like my heart is full of hope..even after us bickering on the phone 2 days ago I still feel hope that things will get better and we can save our marriage and Dr.OOMIRIMIRI spell brought smile back in our marriage contact him today on his email: OOMIRIMIRI@GMAIL.COM OR CALL +2349073244122

    ReplyDelete